Judges Page: Self Produced CD

Instructions

The form you are using contains the information you will need to judge this contest.

The criteria for each category is provided for you. 

I have provided images of the artwork for each CD as well as the audio files.

Upon completion of form- I will tally and publish results. 

Thank You for your help! 

CD #1

Phil Kitze and Friends: Can't Be Wrong
Selected Value: 1
Please use the following criteria: Is this a Blues Music recording? Score Range: 8-10 Straight blues and nuthin' but the blues. Score Range: 5-7 Clearly blues based with a preponderance of the recordings falling within a traditional definition. Some songs leaning more to other recognizable genres such as gospel, rock, country, etc. Score Range: 1-4 Only marginally related to traditional blues stylistically, instrumentally, lyrically and in overall feeling
Selected Value: 1
Please use the following criteria: Quality of Musicianship Score Range: 8-10 National break out stuff. Ranging from some select tracks within a consistent overall presentation to gold from beginning to end. Score Range : 5-7 Professional caliber band/performance. There are songs on the album which catch the ear of a discriminating fan and cause the album to get passed along and recommended to friends. Score Range: 1-4 Quality is good enough to play local gigs on a regular basis. Performance not strong enough to garner attention beyond fixed fan base.
Selected Value: 0
Please use the following criteria: Production Quality, Values, Levels Score Range: 8-10 Very well conceived and executed. Mix is full/three dimensional and feels live. Score Range: 5-7 Overall impression positive. Nothing in the recording distracts from the listening experience. Score Range: 1-4 Ranging from poorly mixed and two dimensional to professional but inconsistent.
Selected Value: 1
Please use the following criteria: Professional Packaging, Ready for the rack at your favorite music outlet? Score Range: 8-10 Artistic, original, informative. A package you like to sit with while listening to the album. Score Range: 5-7 Production quality high and colors/themes hang together cohesively. Score Range: 1-4 Ranging from uninformative and disjointed to adequate.
Selected Value: 1
Please use the following critera: Informative and Professional Score Range: 8-10 Liner gives adequate credit to all participants on the recording and includes a range of information both anecdotal and factual regarding the recording. Score Range: 5-7 Liner gives credit to recording participants only and contains limited information Score Range: 1-4 Very limited information, no credits given

Phil Kitze and Friends: Can't Be Wrong Tracks 1 - 13

Jimmi and the Band of Souls: AQUARius

Tracks 1-10

 

 

jimmi and the bvand of souls artwork.1